CLICK TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE MARRIAGE ENCOURAGEMENT PODCAST!
There’s a version of the Christian life that looks like effort all the way down. Pray more, serve more, do better, fix the next thing about yourself. Work hard enough, perform well enough, get it together enough, then things will be good.
Brad Rhoads left a 22-year law career to fight for marriages, and he wrote a book called The Grace Marriage — but the most important thing he shared in our conversation wasn’t a framework. It was what he heard from God alone in his den one afternoon. “Brad, you’re not okay — and it’s okay.”
He said it was the first time he could actually breathe. All those passages he believed — easy yoke, light burden, rested soul, cease striving — finally had experiential reality. Because up until that moment, his Christian walk felt like a long self-improvement project. And as his mentor put it, he was using the Bible as a self-help guide instead of growing in wonder at the fact that he was loved and adopted.
Often, the way we approach God is the way we approach our spouses. If we believe, somewhere underneath all our theology, that God’s love is still conditional on our performance — that we’re just trying hard enough not to be disappointing — we will treat our spouses the same way. We’ll give love when things are going well and pull it back when they’re not. We’ll keep a ledger, even if we never admit to it.
He calls that a performance-based marriage. And every marriage starts there by default.
“The only person that knows all the bad stuff about you is your wife,” Brad said. “If you don’t get grace, sin will have mastery and control.”
There is no hiding in marriage. There’s nowhere to perform your way into someone’s admiration when they’ve seen the 6am version of you, the scared version, the version that said the wrong thing and knew it immediately. And what Brad is describing — a grace-based marriage — is choosing, deliberately and repeatedly, to love the person who knows the worst about you the way Christ loves us. Not because they’ve earned it. Because grace is never earned.
If you’re in a season where your marriage feels like a transaction — where love is conditional on good behavior — we encourage you to sit with Brad’s testimony and then go listen to our full conversation. The Grace Marriage isn’t a book about trying harder. It’s about finally understanding what you’ve already been given.
Episode Outline
Host: Aaron Smith
Guest: Brad Rhoads
Focus: What grace-based marriage actually looks like — how applying the gospel to your spouse, rather than a performance standard, changes the foundation of your relationship and the way the church should be discipling married couples.
Introduction
- Marriage is the first institution God created — everything flows from it
- Brad left a 22-year law career to fight for marriages
- Grace Marriage exists to equip churches with ongoing marriage ministry, not just premarital prep and crisis counseling
Key Themes
The Marriage That Looked Fun
- Brad and Marilyn built a two-year waiting list for their marriage group without trying
- A young couple came to them for premarital counseling and said, “We want what you have — your marriage looks fun”
- Fun was the result of actually liking and pursuing each other, not a program
The Early Years: Neglect and Misdiagnosis
- Brad put his creative energy and resources into building his law practice and pulled them away from Marilyn immediately after marriage
- Marilyn cried spontaneously two or three times a week; Brad’s diagnosis was that she was “hypersensitive”
- The truth: a neglectful husband, not a needy wife
- Marilyn’s breakthrough — Christ’s sufficiency meant she no longer needed Brad to be her source; “I’m off your roller coaster”
The Intervention
- Two people in Brad’s church came forward and told him he was succeeding gloriously at the things that mattered least and failing at the things that mattered most
- One forced Brad to a marriage conference (cleared his calendar, bought his ticket, invited his father-in-law — then called him)
- One took Brad to lunch every Thursday for six years and verbally pressed him until he agreed to date his wife once a week
- They’ve been on a weekly date for 29 years since
Marriage Doesn’t Thrive Without Intentionality
- The core misconception: “We love each other, so we’re fine” — the one area where people think the sowing-and-reaping rule doesn’t apply
- All you have to do to have a terrible yard is nothing for four weeks; marriage is no different
- The same energy Brad put into growing his law practice had to be redirected toward his marriage
Why the Church Has Left the Marriage Space Open
- Marriage will never be a bigger deal in the home than it is in the church
- The current default: premarital, nothing, then crisis counseling — then lamenting how hard marriage ministry is
- When the church leaves the space open, the world fills it; couples default to busyness, child-centeredness, and financial priority
- Brad’s model: ongoing discipleship that shepherds and pushes couples toward each other
Redefining Success
- Everyone was telling Brad he was doing great — Sunday school teacher, elder, growing law practice, respected in the community
- The people who loved him most told him the truth
- A Harvard professor studied why so many high achievers end up divorced: when people have discretionary time, they put it toward things with measurable results — and relationship rarely shows immediate metrics
- True biblical wealth is things with DNA — wife, children, community — not revenue or status
The Loneliness Epidemic and the Relational Church
- This is likely the loneliest generation in history, despite all the technology
- Six of the Ten Commandments are about relationship with people
- The church often settles for cordial lunches and occasional dinners and calls it community
- What the body of Christ is meant to be: people who walk with, rebuke, encourage, and exhort each other
- Older men and women stepping out of retirement and into discipleship
Performance-Based vs. Grace-Based Marriage
- Performance-based: love is given and taken away based on perception of how you’re being treated
- Grace-based: love is a free gift — not earned, not withdrawn based on behavior
- Gospel application: why did God give you salvation? Not because you impressed him — it’s grace, entirely
- How we love one another: as we’ve been loved (freely, without condition)
- In a performance-based marriage, sin has dominion; in a grace-based marriage, one person’s bad day doesn’t make a bad marriage
Grace Starts With Your Own Walk
- Brad brought performance into his faith — pray more, memorize more, teach Sunday school, be elder
- His mentor called him a “moral narcissist” — using the Bible as a self-help guide instead of growing in wonder at being loved and adopted
- In his den, he heard God say: “Brad, you’re not okay — and it’s okay”
- For the first time, he could breathe; the yoke felt light; rested soul became experiential, not just theological
- People who live under condemnation tend to condemn others; people who rest in grace can love people who are messed up
New Creation Theology
- Do you actually believe the old is gone and the new has come?
- God isn’t seeing your sin through the filter of Jesus — he’s looking at a cleansed, beloved son or daughter
- Satan is the great accuser; remaining sin makes it easy to feel unpleasing to God — but in Christ, you are pleasing
- Song of Solomon parallel: the groom doting over his bride — this is how God sees the redeemed
Key Takeaways
- Marriage thrives on intentionality; neglect it and it dies — regardless of how much you love each other
- The church’s greatest neglect is the space between premarital counseling and marital crisis
- A grace-based marriage is the gospel in practice — moving toward your spouse when they deserve it least
- You cannot give grace to your spouse until you’ve received it yourself; performance-based faith produces performance-based marriage
- Older couples who pursue each other well become a magnetic force that pulls younger couples toward them
- God’s love for you is not contingent on your performance — resting in that changes everything about how you relate to others
Notable Quotes
- “Marriage will never be a bigger deal in the home than it is in the church.” — Brad Rhoads
- “We were succeeding in a glowing way in the things that matter the least, and failing in the things that matter the most.” — Brad Rhoads
- “The only person that knows all the bad stuff about you is your wife. If you don’t get grace, sin will have mastery and control.” — Brad Rhoads
- “Brad, you’re not okay — and it’s okay. Relax.” — Brad Rhoads (recounting what he heard from God)
- “Until I could rest in the fact that I’m still messed up, I could not really enjoy other people that are.” — Brad Rhoads
Resources Mentioned
- The Grace Marriage by Brad Rhoads
- Grace Marriage Ministry — gracemarriage.com
Next Steps / Call to Action
- Go to gracemarriage.com and explore how your church can launch an ongoing marriage discipleship ministry
- If you’re in a performance-based marriage, identify one place this week where you can respond with grace instead of withdrawal
- Ask yourself: is your faith performance-based or grace-based? Spend time in Hebrews 4, John 15, and Psalm 46:10
- Pursue one older couple in your church whose marriage you admire and ask them to speak into yours
- Start a weekly date — not optional, not when things are good — as a non-negotiable rhythm
